In the series: Getting Started with Forestry

Just Say No to High-Grading, Selective Cutting, and Diameter-Limit Cutting

Peter J. Smallidge - State Extension Forester, Cornell Cooperative Extension, Department of Natural Resources, Cornell University, Ithaca

and

Michael C. Greason -  Chief (retired) of the Bureau of Private Land Service, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, Albany, NY

ARTICLE USE: All articles are made available through the Cornell Cooperative Extension News Service, phone: 607-255-9422. Articles are in the public domain and may be used in other publications. Credit should be given to the author(s) and Cornell University Extension News Service. Articles may be used in their entirety, with minimal changes that do not alter the substance or intent of the article, or with revisions approved by the author.

This and other articles are available from the Cornell University Extension Forestry Home Page at
http://www.dnr.cornell.edu/ext/forestrypage/pubs.htm

Currently the prices paid for timber in New York woodlots are good and harvesting activity has increased. However, what may surprise many forest and woodlot owners is that some forestry techniques can limit options for future benefits and enjoyment -- both in the long run and short term. While well-planned timber harvesting can increase your benefits, "high-grading" and related practices should be avoided.

Cutting the best trees (those of highest value) and leaving the low value, often diseased or malformed trees, is too common. This type of forestry is called high-grading, where the highest grade (or value) trees are removed. By cutting only the largest and most valuable trees you remove those best suited to that site. The trees that are less well adapted remain as the next forest and the seed source for future forests. The financial gain of high-grading exist only briefly, yet ownership objectives can be sacrificed for decades. A similar analogy from livestock is the farmer or stable manager who shoots the blue ribbon bull or winning race horse and uses the losers for breeding stock. The quality of the herd, just as the quality of the forest and woodlot, declines rapidly!

In addition to high-grading, similar practices exist with different names. High-grading is often disguised under the name of "diameter-limit cutting". This is a practice that removes all trees above a certain minimum diameter. In some rare situations diameter-limit cutting is appropriate. For example, if old pasture trees are shading the growth of young hardwood saplings. Often however, diameter-limit cutting removes trees of commercial value (say above 12 or 14 inches in diameter) before these trees can attain a more valuable size and add seed and seedlings to the forest. Selective cutting is another technique where high-grading can occur. Selective cutting (generally not recommended) differs from the selection system of silviculture (a legitimate technique). Selective cutting, as commonly practiced, involves selecting the highest quality trees and cutting them. (Technical note: selective cutting by definition can include other activities such as improvement cuts) The selection system involves someone professionally trained in silviculture to select trees from all age and size classes, both high and low quality to produce an uneven-aged forest. Diameter-limit cutting and selective cutting are often rationalized by arguing to remove the bigger trees so the smaller trees can grow. However, the smaller trees may be undesirable species, poor form, or poor heath. By any name, high-grading degrades the value of the forest regardless of the "logic" used by foresters or loggers trying to make a quick buck.

Why does high-grading happen? A common cause for high-grading is greed to maximize immediate profits. Beginning in the early 1970’s, demand for high-value timber increased and sawmills could pay more for certain species. Thus, markets for high-value trees grew stronger while markets for low value trees did not. Further, it costs about the same amount of money to cut and haul a $10 tree as it does to cut and haul a $300 tree of the same size. Another factor is that taxes on forest land not under the NYS 480-a Forest Tax Law can create financial hardships that encourage landowners to maximize immediate profits. The result is that more immediate profit is gained by cutting only the highest value trees, but left behind is a legacy of low quality trees and under-productive forests. This knowledge helps explain high-grading, but doesn’t excuse it.

What are the consequences of high-grading, is it really that bad? One result is that the trees that are left behind won’t grow as quickly as better quality trees and the time until the next harvest is lengthened. In addition, the next harvest will remove the low quality trees previously left so the value at the next harvest will be reduced. If you magnify the practice of high-grading across a region, assuming the demand for wood products remains steady, then more acres must be harvested to meet the demand. While timber harvesting is not bad, accelerated harvesting is not in the best interest of our natural resources and conflicts with a growing demand by the public for accountability of natural resource management. As the value of the land to produce timber crops decreases, the incentive to subdivide and develop increases.

So what can you do to avoid high-grading? One step is to work with competent and professional loggers and foresters. When you select a new refrigerator or car you likely consider several features, including price, reputation, service after the sale, and other long-term benefits. Similarly select your forester and logger. Ask for references, find out if the forester participates in continuing education programs and whether the logger has completed the "Trained Logger Certification" program, make a visit to forests or woodlots where they have worked, and know that the best price may not provide the best treatment for your land. The logger who out bids his competitors for a timber sale by a few percent may be more efficient or may not devote enough effort to ensure your property is left in good condition. Similarly the forester who promises you maximum short-term profit likely doesn’t have in mind the best interests for you and your land. The consequences of selecting an incompetent forester or logger will exist longer than a bad choice on a refrigerator.

Another step to avoid high-grading is to have a written management plan. Your management plan will state your objectives and help keep you on track. The harvesting schedule in your management plan will help you decide when harvesting is appropriate. Just because a forester or logger offers to cut your timber doesn’t mean it’s the best time for your interests. The value of trees increases greatly as trees get bigger, and it’s probably a safe assumption that good markets will continue to exist for high quality trees (although markets fluctuate).

Third, look for creative solutions to remove the low value trees at the same time the high value trees are harvested. A harvest that removes high-value and low-value trees provides financial benefits from the high- and low-value trees and improves the quality of the residual forest. One way is to have the forester mark and the logger skid the low value trees to the log landing. Then you can cut them yourself for firewood, or sell them to a firewood processor. This will require extra effort on the part of the logger and forester, which means you might not make as much money, but the benefits, including even greater profits, will exist a few years down the road.

Finally, get assistance from unbiased people to help you develop long-term objectives and management plans. Master Forest Owner Volunteers are forest owners trained through Cornell Cooperative Extension to provide nontechnical assistance to forest owners. They can help other you think through your management objectives and provide sources of information. Also, NYS Department of Environmental Conservation professional foresters are available for free consultation and can provide technical expertise and guidance on forest ma

nagement. Both of these groups of people can provide free, unbiased information and advice that will help you avoid some of the pitfalls of practicing short-sighted forestry. The Catskill Forest Association and New York Forest Owners Association are landowner groups dedicated to helping other landowners enjoy their forest land. Contact your county office of Cornell Cooperative Extension or the nearest DEC office for more information.

return to article listing